Research abuse means that people who take part in research are intentionally harmed, put at risk, or treated unfairly. This goes against the three golden rules of research to respect people, do no harm, and to be fair.
Before the 1970’s, there was not a way to make sure all researchers followed these rules. Many researchers acted ethically. However, some ignored the safety and well-being of the people who took part in research. These studies were usually approved by the institutions where they took place. In some cases, the research was paid for or run by the U.S. government.
What are some examples of past research abuses?
Research abuse means that people who take part in research are intentionally harmed, put at risk, or treated unfairly. This goes against the three golden rules of research to respect people, do no harm, and to be fair.
Before the 1970’s, there was no way to make sure all researchers followed these rules. Many researchers acted ethically. However, some ignored the safety and well-being of the people who took part in research. These studies were usually approved by the institutions where they took place. In some cases, the research was paid for or run by the U.S. government.
What are some examples of past research abuse?
From 1932 to 1972 a research study, now known as the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, caused harm to black men. Men in this study were not told they had syphilis. They were told they had “bad blood”; a term used for various illnesses. When penicillin was discovered as a cure, they were not given the treatment. This is an example of abuse in research.
Although these men were not injected with syphilis by the researchers, they were denied proper treatment. There have been, however, other cases where researchers exposed people to harmful or infectious substances on purpose. In some cases, this was done to children who were not able to give consent. There have also been past instances of researchers recklessly exposing people to radiation. In many cases, people were not aware and did not give consent.
In other cases, consent was not always freely given. Research was sometimes done with people in prison or in the military. But researchers didn’t always make sure people felt free to refuse to take part. Research abuses were not limited to the United States. Experiments on prisoners in Nazi concentration camps injured or killed many people. Prisoners of war were subjected to medical torture in Japan.
Sadly, there are many more examples of past research abuse. It is important for all researchers to openly acknowledge the past so that similar actions never happen again.
Am I protected from research abuse?
Since Tuskegee, much has changed. There are many safeguards to protect the safety, privacy, and rights of research participants. The U.S. Office of Human Research Protections was established to protect the rights, welfare, and well-being of research participants.
- Being in a study is voluntary. People are free to decide if they want to join the study. They can also stop at any time.
- All human research is checked by a group called an Institutional Review Board (IRB). Members of the IRB are not part of the study team. Their job is to protect the rights, safety, and well-being of research volunteers.
- In almost every study, researchers must have informed consent of everyone who takes part in a clinical research study. Informed consent means people are given all the important information about the study before they sign up.
- There are some very limited situations where informed consent may not be required. For example, research may be done for treatment of medical emergencies when the person can’t give consent. However, there are very strict rules about when such research can occur.
Remembering the ways that past research has harmed people can help to prevent such harms from occurring again. But we should not let the errors of the past get in the way of advances for the future. Clinical trials help find safe and effective ways to prevent and treat diseases.